2022
Outstanding Lighting Design - Sam Mence - Heathers the Musical
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical - Tiaana Quest as "Martha Dunnstock" - Heathers the Musical
Outstanding Direction of a Musical - Joshua Downs - Heathers the Musical

2021
Best Make-Up & Hair Design - Geena Hine and Dylan Shore - The Addams Family
Best Props Design - Celia Talbot - The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (Abridged)
Best Lighting Design - Shane Richardson - The Addams Family
Best Costume Design - Helen Chessum - The Addams Family
Cameo Award - Joel McGeorge as "Lurch" - The Addams Family
Best Make-Up & Hair Design - Geena Hine and Dylan Shore - The Addams Family

2019
Best Leading Actor in a Musical - Adeel Surendran as "Joseph" - Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

2018
Best Lighting Design - Molloy - Be More Chill
Best Costume Design - Helen Chessum - The Wiz
Best Vocal Work by a Musical Company - Be More Chill
Best Supporting Actor in a Musical - Lucas Haugh as "The Squip" - Be More Chill
Best Leading Actor in a Musical - Hadley R Taylor as "Jeremy Heere" - Be More Chill
Best Direction of a Musical - Adam Spedding - Be More Chill

2017
Best Sound Design - Shane Richardson - In The Heights
Best Lighting Design - Shane Richardson and Adam Spedding - In The Heights
Best Set Design - Hamish McGregor and Chris Scott - In The Heights
Best Supporting Ensemble - In The Heights
Best Leading Actor in a Musical - Joe Nathan as "Usnavi" - In The Heights
Best Choreography - Nomi Cohen - In The Heights
Best Musical Direction - Andy Manning and Josh Clark - In The Heights
Best Direction of a Musical - Adam Spedding - In The Heights
Best Musical - In The Heights

2016
Best Lighting Design - Paul Richardson - Dreamgirls
Best Youth Performer - Lucy Maher as "Ursula" - Disney's The Little Mermaid JR
Best Supporting Actor in a Musical - Brady Peeti as "Jimmy 'Thunder' Early" - Dreamgirls

2015
Cameo Award - Brady Peeti as "Bullfrog" - Honk!

2014
Best Set Design - Hamish McGregor - Avenue Q
Best Director - Hamish McGregor - Avenue Q

2013
Best Sound Design - MPA - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Best Costume Design - Jason Te Mete - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Best Vocal Work by a Company - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Best Supporting Ensemble - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Best Supporting Female - Emma Carr as "Olive Ostrovsky" - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Best Actress - Alex Foster as "Rona Peretti" - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Best Actor - Nick Purdie as "William Barfee" - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Best Director - Jason Te Mete - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Best Musical - The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee

2009
Best Hair & Makeup - Seussical The Musical
Best Supporting Female - Amanda Burnett as "Mayzie La Bird" - Seussical The Musical
Best Musical Direction - Robin Kelly - Seussical The Musical

2007
Best Play - It Runs In The Family

2006
Best Hair & Makeup - Mary Dyer - Wizard of Oz
Best Props Design - Celia Talbot - Wizard of Oz

2004
Best Special Effects - Frankenstein the Panto

2003
Best Special Effects - Guards! Guards!
Best Props Design - Celia Talbot - Guards! Guards!
Best Sound Design - Darrell Rogers - Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Best Lead Female in a Musical - Patricia Bell as "Narrator" - Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

2002
Best Special Effects - Mort
Best Choreography - Theresa Williams - Nunsense